If the mechanics of how the
Colorado River got into the Grand Canyon looks a little strange, the
course of Dolores River from Dolores to Delta CO appears to be out of
touch with reality. (Please see the
Dolores River 3-D map.)
To the northwest of the town of Dolores, the topographic (and
stratigraphic) gradient tilts down to the southwest. The logical route
for the river would be a southwestward “down the mountain”
course that would form the expected right angle to the contour lines.
The wacko river travels northwestward across this section and is thus
parallel to the contour lines.

Further downstream at the boundary between Montezuma and
Dolores Counties, there is a large (50+ acres) gravel pit on the
southwest rim of Dolores Canyon. At some time in the past, the river
actually occupied this spot on the rim, which is now over 600 feet
above the present river. There is a gradient downhill from here to the
southwest. So naturally, our river ignores the downhill route and turns
due north with its path climbing diagonally over 1,000 vertical feet up
the side of an anticline. (As measured from the gravel pit on the rim
to the top of the anticline.) The river has actually dug a 2,000-foot
deep canyon through the anticline; but how and why did the river take
this path in the first place?

The other side of the anticline drops 2,500 feet down into
Disappointment Valley. This would be a perfect location for the river
to use the “straight down the mountain” route. However, the
Dolores River does not believe in the law of gravity and takes a
diagonal route – including two imbedded meanders, both of which
have short sections where the river turns directly back uphill. A sane
river would continue all the way down into the valley where it could
find an easy route. Just before reaching the valley floor, the Dolores
turns left to dig a cross-hill canyon in the side of the valley en
route to Slick Rock.
From Slick Rock, the river travels a few miles through
canyons to reach Big Gypsum Valley. Big Gypsum is a long, narrow
northwest to southeast oriented valley. Instead of entering the valley
via one of the ends, our loony river enters it from the southwest at
the midpoint of the valley. At least the river begins to behave
normally at this point and follows the valley to the northwest –
for all of three miles. Although Big Gypsum Valley continues northwest
for another six miles, the Dolores takes a dogleg to the right directly
into the 1,000-foot high cliffs. For the next six linear miles, but
more like 20 as the river flows, the Dolores follows a highly
convoluted path through canyons in a path that roughly parallels Big
Gypsum Valley but never finding it again.
A few more convoluted miles and the Dolores River wanders
into Paradox Valley. (Understandably, whoever named it was also a
little perplexed.) Paradox Valley is a 20-mile long northwest to
southeast valley. A logical river might be expected to travel
lengthwise down such a valley. Not our Dolores. It emerges from a
1,500-foot deep canyon at the midpoint on the southwest side of the
valley, cuts straight across the valley toward the northeast (plus a
meander or two), and immediately dives into another 1,500-foot deep
canyon in the northeast wall of the valley.
For the remainder of its route to Gateway, the Dolores
behaves more like a normal River. However, tributaries such as Roc (no
“k”) and Salt Creeks continue the strange behavior.

All of the above wanderings are completely illogical by
today’s topography, but we must remember the river (actually the
ancestral San Juan River) pioneered this path during the Eocene. Some
45 to 50 million years ago this was a simple downhill route from the
San Juan Basin (on the Colorado/New Mexico border) toward the north
where the old river emptied into the Lake Uinta lowlands. This was when
the river defined its course, started the entrenchment process, and has
maintained this entrenched course ever since.
The anticline had not risen yet during the Eocene. The
northwest to southeast valleys did not exist either. The valleys were
originally occupied with salt and gypsum deposits laid down 250 - 300
million years ago as evaporates from an ancient sea. These deposits
were then covered by other sediments until they were exposed (or at
least were near the surface) during the Miocene. At this point ground
water dissolved the old evaporates, and the Dolores/Colorado River
system carried them west to Utah’s deserts. Then, whatever was
left of the overlying sediments (if anything) collapsed to form the
valleys.
The current southwestward tilt in the strata from Dolores
downstream to the anticline developed after the river was entrenched in
this area. (The same southwestward tilt extends southeast of Dolores to
include Lost Creek Canyon.)
The meanders in the river are a product of the silt flats
that formed 5.4 million years ago as the whole Colorado River system
backed up behind the rising Wasatch. Finally, the canyons were
excavated after the Colorado River overflowed through the Kaibab and
canyon
cutting worked its way back upstream. More information about the
evolution of the Dolores River follows.